At a Glance:
Decoding the 3 Stove Fuel Sources
Our Gas vs Electric Stove Review
What’s better: a gas vs electric range? Both of these cooking range options have their pros and cons. Ultimately, your choice may come down to personal preference, depending on whether you’re a foodie who cooks up ambitious dishes or who’s looking for easy cleanup. And then there are other factors to consider, such as how much it costs to repair each type of stove or the upfront cost to own one.
In this stove buying guide, we’ll break down what to look for in a stove, starting with whether it is gas or electric and then comparing critical factors like the cost and reliability of each appliance. Soon, you’ll be able to determine which one is the best fit for you and your cooking needs!
Discover the Best Range Deals
Colder's carries stoves in every fuel source and design—see what's new today!
Shop NowDecoding the 3 Stove Fuel Sources
There are three common stove fuel types: gas, electric, and induction. Although induction’s popularity is on the rise, gas and electric ranges are by far more common and the more affordable choices.
- Gas stoves are considered the closest to restaurant-grade cooking appliances, making them ideal picks for avid foodies. They offer precise temperature control, but they also require a gas hookup.
- Electric stoves are commonly found in rental units but are also popular choices in households that do light cooking and don’t need the most performance, features, or output. They’re easy to clean, don’t require gas connections, and they often come equipped with innovative features that rival the quality of gas cooking.
- Induction stoves are the newest generation of ranges, which are catching on in eco-conscious homes looking for an alternative to gas without sacrificing performance. They are safe, energy efficient, and speed up the cooking process.
Learn More: What to Look for When Shopping for Ranges [Range Buying Guide]
Our Gas vs Electric Stove Review
When comparing gas vs electric range options, you need to consider more than the initial cost of the stove. What about its energy efficiency, potential repair costs, and overall reliability? We’ll walk through each of these topics in depth, comparing the gas vs electric stove pros and cons and recommending our favorite gas range and electric range picks.
Gas Stove Cost
The first question you’re probably asking is, how much does a gas stove cost? They can range from $400 to $2,100, but they can be even more if you’re looking for all the bells and whistles. Electric stoves are typically less, ranging between $360 and $1,800. Don’t forget to consider the price of installation, which ranges from $300 to $2,200, plus the cost of a gas hookup if you don’t already have one.
Gas Stove Efficiency
Initial cost isn’t the only thing that matters. Gas vs electric stove efficiency is important too. Comparing the gas vs electric stove monthly cost, gas is a cheaper fuel source, so gas stoves cost less per month to operate, leading to lower energy bills. In terms of energy transfer, though, gas stoves transfer energy with an efficiency of 32%, which pales in comparison to electric’s 75-80% efficiency and induction’s 85% efficiency.
Gas Stove Repair Cost
According to HomeAdvisor, the average cost for a stove repair is $100–500, which includes all types of ranges. Repairing the burner coil or a faulty switch costs less while replacing or repairing a glass stovetop (electric) and installing brand-new burners (gas) will cost more. On average, it costs 20% more to repair gas appliances, depending on the issue.
Gas Stove Reliability
In terms of reliability and durability, gas ranges are often more durable and easier to maintain. because they have fewer parts. They also tend to last longer (15 years when well-maintained), but according to Consumer Reports, electric stoves tend to outperform their gas counterparts.
Learn More: 3 Show-Stopping 48 Inch Ranges for Your Kitchen
Recommended Gas Stoves
At the end of the day, gas ranges are still a popular choice for households, and no other fuel source provides the same restaurant quality of a gas stove. Here are a few great examples to consider which features and designs we recommend buyers look for when shopping for a gas stove.
KitchenAid 30” Stainless Steel Slide In Gas Range
Shop This KitchenAid Gas Range
This is the dream range for the avid home baker. Powerful convection cooking will make your baked goods moist and flaky, while a steam rack converts your recipes from conventional settings to the perfect setting for artisanal breads and specialty desserts. Not only that, but cleanup is easy with KitchenAid’s Aqualift cleaning technology which can clean your oven in less than an hour without odors and at a low temperature.
⭐ Featured KitchenAid KSGG700ESS Review:
“Love this range! All burners are so convenient! Oven works perfectly, love the steamer for the cake. Also the way the shelves are in the oven. Easy to grab.”
Frigidaire 30” Black Freestanding Gas Range
Shop This Frigidaire Gas Range
A gas range doesn’t have to cost a fortune. Take this Frigidaire gas stove for example. Its sleek design finished in black is complemented by great features, including a power burner with up to 17,000 BTUs of heat output. We give points to sealed burners, which not only simplify cleanup but make them more durable. While simple in design, over 3,400 users give this setup a perfect 5/5 rating.
⭐ Featured Frigidaire FFGF3054TB Review:
“I love my new stove! It is easy to work and cooks my food very well. This stove is easy to clean. Would definitely recommend!”
Frigidaire Gallery 30” Black Stainless Steel Freestanding Gas Range with Air Fry
Shop This Frigidaire Gallery Gas Range
Another time-saving option for busy families, this pick features quick preheat. This freestanding gas range also features Air Fry for healthier versions of your favorite foods. The 5-burner cooktop features a flexible design with different burners that are tailor-made for different tasks, whether you need to boil, simmer, or set up a griddle.
⭐ Featured Frigidaire Gallery FGGH3047VD Review:
“The range takes some getting used to, but I'm very satisfied with it and since I've been using electric for so long, I'm enjoying the quality of cooking that comes with gas.”
Electric Stove Cost
What about the electric range vs gas cost? In general, electric ranges cost less than gas stoves up front, with prices ranging between $360 and $1,800. They also cost less to install, and you may be able to install them yourself (in most cases, it’s as simple as sliding into place and plugging in the power).
Electric Stove Efficiency
In terms of energy efficiency, electric stoves transfer energy more efficiently than gas (with only 20-25% energy loss), but they cost more per month to operate, leading to higher utility bills.
Electric Stove Repair Cost
According to Angi, electric oven repairs tend to cost less, ranging between $100 to $250 while gas oven repairs tend to cost more with an average of $100 to $600. Some repairs you may be able to DIY, but oftentimes, you’ll need to call a professional, especially when it comes to electrical repairs.
Electric Stove Reliability
While gas stoves tend to last for 15 years, electric stoves rival them with an average 13-year life expectancy. They are fairly durable and easier to clean thanks to their smooth cooktop surfaces. With that said, in the case of a power outage, an electric stove won’t be operatable while gas stoves can be used.
Learn More: Air Fry vs. Convection: Which Oven Setting is Better? [Bonus: Recipes!]
Recommended Electric Stoves
Despite the way they’re portrayed, electric ranges are still powerful, useful cooking appliances. There is a learning curve for cooks who are used to using gas, but users typically catch on fast. When searching for an electric range, consider looking for features like the ones from our following recommended electric ranges.
Maytag 30” Fingerprint Resistant Stainless Steel Freestanding Electric Range with Air Fryer
Shop This Maytag Electric Range
This user-friendly electric range features some of the functions you might expect to see in a gas stove like Air Fry and convection cooking. It also offers a 5-burner cooktop for ample cooking space, and when you’re done cooking, you can simply wipe down the smooth ceramic glass cooktop. For home cooks who want some of the special features of popular gas ranges but prefer electric cooktops, this is a great option.
⭐ Featured Maytag MER7700LZ Review:
“Love this range! More features than I even realized at first. Stovetop heats a 12" cast iron pan quickly and evenly, much better than our old glass top. Two large burners in front will work well for canning with large pots. The air fryer feature is a welcome surprise! All is working well and looks great in our kitchen.”
KitchenAid 30” Stainless Freestanding Electric Convection Range
Shop This KitchenAid Electric Range
Capacity, capacity, capacity. That’s just one of the great features this electric stove offers, with over 6 cubic feet of oven space to bake, broil, and braise to your heart’s desire. You’ll look good while preparing meals too with this model’s professionally inspired design, matched by additional features like Even-Heat True Convection in the oven and dual heating elements on the stovetop. It’s an overall cooking delight home chefs will enjoy making meals on.
⭐ Featured KitchenAid KFEG500ESS Review:
“We purchased this Range about 4 months ago and we have been very happy with it. The controls are very user friendly and easy to use. We highly recommend this product.”
Samsung 30” White Glass Slide In Induction Range
Shop This Samsung Electric Range
This stove’s induction cooktop is paired with an electric oven equipped with convection cooking and Air Fry, making this range an all-around powerhouse that gives users more versatility during dinner prep. If you want all the bells and whistles, plus induction cooking, in a sleek modern package, this is the oven for you from its modern design to Wi-Fi connectivity that lets you control range settings via a smart device or with your own voice.
⭐ Featured Samsung NE63BB861112 Review:
“So far, this range has worked flawlessly...the induction top cooks fast, cooks evenly, and it is easy to clean up.”
Ultimately, gas and electric stoves both have their pros and cons. If you want an intuitive user experience and easy cleanup as well as a lower initial cost, an electric stove is a great option. If you love to cook and want to experiment in the kitchen and pay lower monthly utility bills, then a gas stove might be for you. With a selection of ranges for every budget, Colder’s is the best place to shop for ranges from top brands in the Milwaukee area. Shop our entire stock online or visit us today to learn more!
Why Trust Colder’s?
Since 1942, we at Colder's pride ourselves on offering value, selection, and service. Serving Southeastern Wisconsin with four showrooms that stock quality name-brand furniture, appliances, and mattresses, Colder’s is sure to house exactly what you are looking for. And if you can't find it on our floors, chances are, we can order it for you. As a local, family-owned company, we are always doing our best to provide the highest value at the lowest cost to everyone who walks through our doors.
Colder’s is committed not only to continuously offering can’t-miss sales but also to working with each customer, making sure that you take advantage of every possible markdown — that’s our best price guarantee. Still need help? We offer zero percent appliance and furniture financing for your home needs!
Shop Stoves at Colder’s
Don’t put off happiness — and shop cooking appliances online for unbeatable prices at Colder’s. Our friendly experts are always happy to help you learn more about gas vs electric stove models, whether you call us at 414-476-1574 or use our online chat feature. Better yet, stop by one of our Colder’s locations in West Allis, Oak Creek, Delafield, and Grafton, Wisconsin to touch, see, feel, and experience home products that fulfill your dreams. Visit us today!
Learn More: Double Oven Electric Ranges: Best Brands