At a Glance:
Shopping Local West Allis Mattress Stores vs Big Box
How Colder’s Outdoes the Other West Allis Mattress Stores
Are you a local asking yourself, “Where is the best place to buy a mattress in West Allis?” There are dozens of mattress stores Milwaukee, so knowing which one to pick is easier said that done. But at Colder’s, we understand buyers want a mattress dealer that offers a wide selection of trusted brands with irresistible savings and quality service. To get that, you need a team that understands sleep health and how to pair people with the right mattress. At Colder’s, you’ll find all of this and more—from knowledgeable staff to affordable and quality brands like Restonic and Sierra Sleep.
With us on your side, you don’t need to know how to buy a mattress. We can help you make the right decision with prices on top brands other local mattress stores can’t compete with.
Discover the Best Mattress Deals
For the sleep you deserve, shop West Allis mattresses at a Colder's near you!
Shop NowShopping Local West Allis Mattress Stores vs Big Box
Anyone who has searched “local mattress stores near me” already knows the struggle of finding a reliable retailer. It may be tempting to choose a chain for the job, but there are several reasons you should shop locally for a mattress instead of heading to a big box store. The benefits of choosing a local mattress West Allis, WI store include:
Better Service
Because they’re smaller, local retailers provide a more personalized and attentive shopping experience. With a smaller customer base, local mattress shops can take the time to understand individual preferences and offer tailored recommendations, ensuring customers find a mattress that suits their specific needs.
We’re Part of the Community
Additionally, independent mattress stores in West Allis are part of the embedded into the community. For example, here at Colder’s, we are proud partners with Ronald McDonald House and City of Hope in West Allis, WI, helping the next generation of West Allis to have better lives by way of community outreach.
Supporting local retailers also contributes to the local economy, creating jobs and stimulating the local economy. In contrast to big box stores, independent mattress retailers often carry a curated selection of high-quality products, emphasizing craftsmanship and customer satisfaction.
When you choose Colder’s as your mattress Milwaukee store, you can have peace of mind knowing you’re helping the local economy while also redeeming exclusive mattress buys, can’t-miss mattress deals, and price-match guarantees on the latest mattress brands and models.
Learn More: Check Out Our Favorite Restonic Mattress Models [Brand Guide]
How Colder’s Outdoes the Other West Allis Mattress Stores
We’ll say it. Other West Allis mattress stores don’t compare to Colder’s, and here’s why.
We’re Experts in Sleep Health
Colder’s is committed to providing sleep health solutions to families in our community. We know choosing the right mattress can drastically improve your sleep quality, even if you’ve already been practicing sleep hygiene tips. Our expert team is ready to guide you in your sleep journey whether you are dealing with sleep disorders, seeking effective sleep solutions, or looking to replace that old sunken mattress. We can help guide you to the mattress comfort or construction that will best suit you.
We Offer Mattress Delivery
Whether you’re in the market for a mattress, a home appliance, or furniture, Colder’s offers a Lifetime Delivery Membership that allows you to save big on delivery. For a one-time fee, you can receive lifetime delivery benefits whenever you shop at Colder’s. This includes mattresses! Especially if you’re updating your bedroom suite as well, this is a great option. If you’ve been searching “mattress delivery near me,” you’ve just found your solution.
We Provide Mattress Protection Plans
Colder’s offers 5-year protection plans so that you can rest easy (literally) knowing your mattress is covered should something unexpected happen.
DoubleBack Credits
As proud Restonic mattress retailers, we offer DoubleBack credits whenever you buy a Restonic mattress. What does that mean? You get $2 back for every $1 you spend on a Restonic mattress to put toward other furniture purchases. Again, if you’re doing an entire bedroom makeover, this is an excellent option.
How to Buy a Mattress
When it comes to understanding how to buy a mattress, there are several factors to consider. In addition to knowing where to find a good mattress, you need to consider mattress comfort level, mattress size, mattress brand, and mattress type. Each of these factors will help you narrow your mattress shop search and find a local mattress that fits all your criteria.
Shop by Mattress Comfort Level
Mattress comfort level, also referred to as mattress firmness, indicates how soft or hard a mattress feels. At Colder’s, you can choose between ultra plush, plush, medium plush, medium, firm, and extra firm mattresses. You may also see the firmness rated out of 10. This range goes from extra soft to soft (1-3), medium soft to medium firm (4-6), and firm to extra firm (7-10).
On the one hand, mattress comfort is a personal preference. Some would rather feel nestled into their mattress while others prefer feeling on top of their mattress. On the other hand, there are some general rules of thumb to help guide you. Here’s a breakdown of which firmness level is best for what kind of sleeper:
- Extra Soft to Soft ➨Ideal for side sleepers who weigh under 130 pounds.
- Medium Soft to Medium Firm ➨Ideal for sleepers who weigh between 130 to 230 pounds and generally ideal for side and back sleepers.
- Firm to Extra Firm ➨Ideal for sleepers who weigh over 230 pounds, some back sleepers, and stomach sleepers.
Shop by Mattress Size
With a selection ranging from twin all the way up to California king mattresses, you can shop mattresses for the entire family at Colder’s. A full list of sizes includes twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king. What size is best for you is largely a personal preference and also depends on the size and layout of your bedroom. Children’s bedrooms tend to be smaller and floor space is reserved for playing, so a twin bed is the go-to option. Queen and king beds are preferred for couples in primary bedrooms.
Shop by Mattress Brand
We proudly carry top mattress brands for every budget and sleep type. Learn more about our top-selling mattress brands below.
Restonic Mattress
Restonic, a brand with a heritage dating back to 1938, is renowned for its diverse mattress construction, incorporating materials like innerspring, memory foam, and wrapped coils to cater to a range of sleep preferences. They have been the recipient of the Women’s Choice Award for Excellence in Brand Experience every year since 2011.
Queen Restonic mattresses range from around $600 on sale to over $5,000. They’re ideal for those who want to strike a balance between affordability and luxury. If you’ve been searching “Restonic mattress near me,” you’ll be happy to know that Colder’s offers a range of Restonic mattresses.
Scott Living Mattress
Scott Living is a sub-brand of Restonic, created in partnership with Jonathan and Drew Scott, who are known for their HGTV show, Property Brothers. They offer a line of specially designed hybrid mattresses.
Queen Scott Living mattresses range in price at around $2,000 to $5,000. Like Restonic, Scott Living mattresses are ideal for those who want to strike a balance between affordability and luxury. Our DoubleBack program applies to Scott Mattresses as well!
Sierra Sleep Mattress
Sierra Sleep, an Ashley brand, offers memory foam, gel memory foam, hybrid, innerspring, and wrapped coil options with the majority of options falling under the memory foam or hybrid categories.
Queen Sierra Sleep mattresses range from around $250 to $1,300. This is a highly affordable mattress brand that is ideal for budget shoppers.
Shop by Mattress Type
If you now the right mattress type for your sleep habits, you’re one step closer to better rest. We can get you there with our selection of top-rated mattress in every comfort type.
Innerspring Mattresses
Innerspring mattresses are coil-based, and they’re known for their excellent edge support, bounce, temperature regulation, and affordability. They tend to be weaker in terms of pressure relief, motion isolation, durability, and noise (thanks to their signature squeak).
We Recommend: Restonic Huron Innerspring Euro Top Queen Mattress
This Restonic mattress is constructed with foam-encased open coils, layers of super soft foam, and a quilt covering to offer temperature regulation for hot sleepers. It’s an ideal choice for sleepers who want the support of springs with a bit more of the soft comfort of foam. We also love the soft touch and detail of the Euro top, adding another layer of luxury to every night’s rest regimen.
Pocketed Coil Mattresses
Unlike traditional spring mattresses, pocketed coil beds are made with individually wrapped coils that move independently, reducing the transfer of motion across the bed, making them an ideal choice for couples or light sleepers. Additionally, pocketed coil mattresses provide targeted support, conforming to the body's contours and promoting proper spinal alignment. Many individuals appreciate the comfort, support, and reduced motion transfer that pocketed coil mattresses bring to the bedroom, especially sleepers who aren’t ready to commit to a memory foam bed.
We Recommend: Restonic DuetSleep by Visionary Sleep Somerset Wrapped Coil Plush Tight Top Queen Mattress
Shop This Restonic Pocketed Coil Mattress
This Restonic mattress was tailor-made for hot sleepers. A layer of TempBalance Gel Foam right under the quilt covering brings relief all night long and instant comfort when you lie down. This mattress is a great option if you want a mattress that offers both pressure relief and support.
Memory Foam Mattresses
Memory foam mattresses are arguably superior when it comes to offering pressure relief, motion isolation, and low noise, although some sleepers comment on the lacking in edge support, bounce, and temperature regulation. However, mattress brands are well aware of these issues, and many of today’s memory foam mattresses are designed around these problems. Models from Restonic, Scott Living, and Sierra Sleep by Ashley are some of the best options on the market today.
We Recommend: Sierra Sleep by Ashley Chime 8” Memory Foam Medium Tight Top Queen Mattress in a Box
Shop This Sierra Sleep Memory Foam Mattress
This Sierra Sleep memory foam mattress is a crowd pleaser thanks to its low price and medium comfort level. Medium mattresses tend to be a great compromise for couples of differing weights and sleeping positions. Additionally, this mattress is made of hypoallergenic material, keeping dust mites, pollen, mold, and pet dander at bay.
★ Featured Sierra Sleep Chime Review:
“Mattress didn't take long to expand to full size and it's very comfortable. Would recommend to anyone needing a new mattress.”
Gel Memory Foam Mattresses
Gel memory foam mattresses have gained popularity for their unique combination of support and temperature regulation. A notable benefit is their ability to contour to the body, providing personalized support and alleviating pressure points for enhanced comfort. The infusion of gel into the memory foam helps dissipate heat, addressing a common issue with traditional memory foam mattresses, and promoting a cooler sleep environment. Gel memory foam mattresses make them a popular choice for those seeking a balance between body-conforming support and temperature regulation.
We Recommend: Sierra Sleep by Ashley Millennium Luxury 14” Gel Memory Foam Cushion Firm Tight Top Queen Mattress in a Box
Shop This Sierra Sleep by Ashley Gel Memory Foam Mattress
This mattress is unique for its charcoal-infused gel memory foam and green tea-infused support foam base, which help to block moisture and odor and keep your mattress fresh. Sleepers will enjoy the body-contouring support of this mattress, and with a firm comfort level, it’s ideal for back and stomach sleepers.
Hybrid Mattresses
Hybrid mattresses combine innerspring with other materials like memory foam and gel memory foam. They offer great bounce and temperature regulation and are better suited for sleepers bigger in stature who enjoy the softness of memory foam but need a little more support.
We Recommend: Restonic ComfortCare Patina Hybrid Extra Firm Tight Top Queen Mattress
Shop This Restonic Hybrid Mattress
This hybrid Restonic mattress includes gel foam, support foam, gel memory foam, and 800 individually wrapped coils with foam encasement. Thanks to its extra firm comfort level, this mattress is ideal for heavier weight sleepers and stomach sleepers who need an extra supportive mattress.
Pillow Top Mattresses
Pillow top mattresses are celebrated for their luxurious comfort and plush feel, making them an appealing option for those who prefer a softer sleeping surface. The added padding, often stitched into the top layer of the mattress, provides an extra layer of cushioning, which can be especially beneficial for individuals with joint or back pain.
We Recommend: Sierra Sleep by Ashley M627 Limited Edition Hybrid Plush Pillow Top Queen Mattress
Shop This Sierra Sleep Pillow Top Mattress
For those who like to feel like they’re sleeping on a plush and fluffy cloud, this budget-friendly Sierra Sleep mattress is the perfect choice. With layers of super soft foam, zoned plush support foam, and gel support memory foam along with wrapped coils, this mattress offers comfort and impressive edge support. It is ideal for side sleepers and lighter weight back sleepers.
★ Featured Sierra Sleep M627 Review:
“Very comfortable. Reasonable price. Would buy again.”
Euro Top Mattresses
Euro top mattresses are appreciated for their refined design, offering a plush and luxurious surface that provides additional comfort and support. The extra padding in the Euro top is sewn directly under the mattress cover, creating a seamless and aesthetically pleasing appearance. This design enhances the overall sleep experience by offering a softer feel without sacrificing underlying support.
We Recommend: Restonic Scott Living Addison Wrapped Coil Euro Top Queen Mattress
Shop This Scott Living Euro Top Mattress
This supportive and comfortable Euro top mattress features foam-encased coils, gel-infused memory foam, medium and soft support foam, and a cool-to-the-touch cover to help decrease heat retention. This mattress is ideal for those looking for edge support and pressure relief. It strikes a balance between softness and support, making it ideal for a variety of sleeper types.
Learn More: Everything You Want to Know About Scott Living Mattresses
Once you’ve decided on a mattress, you may need a few more things to make your bedroom oasis complete. Colder’s also offers mattress foundations in case the mattress or bed frame you’ve chosen requires one. You can also browse mattress sets that pair together popular mattress and bed frame choices to simplify the shopping process. Out of all the mattress stores West Allis shoppers can choose, Colder’s hits all the marks. If you’re searching for a West Allis mattress store, you’ll quickly understand why locals choose Colder’s West Allis store. Stop by today and test out mattresses in person. Stop
Why Trust Colder’s?
Since 1942, we at Colder's pride ourselves on offering value, selection, and service. Serving Southeastern Wisconsin with four showrooms that stock quality name-brand furniture, appliances, and mattresses, Colder’s is sure to house exactly what you are looking for. And if you can't find it on our floors, chances are, we can order it for you. As a local, family-owned company, we are always doing our best to provide the highest value at the lowest cost to everyone who walks through our doors.
Colder’s is committed not only to continuously offering can’t-miss sales but also to working with each customer, making sure that you take advantage of every possible markdown — that’s our best price guarantee. Still need help? We offer zero percent appliance and furniture financing for your home needs!
Shop Mattresses at Colder’s
Don’t put off happiness — and shop mattresses online for unbeatable prices at Colder’s. Our friendly experts are always happy to help you learn why Colder’s is named one of the best mattress stores West Allis shoppers can choose, whether you call us at 414-476-1574 or use our online chat feature. Better yet, stop by one of our Colder’s locations in West Allis, Oak Creek, Delafield, and Grafton, Wisconsin to touch, see, feel, and experience home products that fulfill your dreams. Visit us today!
Learn More: What is the Best Queen Mattress in a Box?