At a Glance:
Why We’re the Mattress Stores Milwaukee Chooses
Since you spend about one-third of your life sleeping, choosing a mattress is a weighty decision. Whether it’s finding a bed that offers support and fits your bedroom space or a bed for you and your partner, you need to find a mattress that suits both of your needs. That’s all to say that the quest to find the best mattress and best mattress store Milwaukee begins with understanding the various options available, and at Colder’s, we want to make that an easy experience.
In this mattress buying guide, we’ll discuss how to choose a mattress based on a variety of factors like comfort, size, and material. Then, we’ll recommend some of the best mattresses that target common sleep problems.
Discover Mattress Deals
Get back to the sleep quality you love with reliable mattresses from Colder's.
Shop NowHow to Choose a Mattress
There are many factors to consider when choosing a mattress. First, consider your most common sleep position. Do you prefer sleeping on your back, side, or stomach? This has major implications for which mattress is best for you. In addition to sleep position, you’ll need to consider the comfort, size, and material of your mattress. You’ll also want to evaluate different brands, mattress stores, and reviews. Keep reading for a breakdown of each of these factors.
Learn More: 5 Most Comfortable Mattress Models
By Mattress Comfort
Mattresses are often labeled by their comfort level. It’s all about how soft or hard your mattress is. Comfort labels include extra firm, firm, medium, medium plush, plush, and ultra plush. As a general rule of thumb, plush mattresses are best suited for side sleepers and lighter weight individuals. A firm mattress is ideal for a back sleeper because it offers pressure relief and extra support.
Here’s a simple breakdown:
✅Side Sleepers: medium, medium plush, plush, or ultra plush
✅Stomach and Back Sleepers: medium, firm, or extra firm
By Mattress Size
Any mattress size guide will include these common dimensions: twin, twin XL, full, queen, California king, and king. Twin and full beds are popular options for children’s bedrooms while queen and king beds are popular for primary bedrooms. The size of your room and bed frame will ultimately determine the best mattress size for you, but don’t forget to account for the size of the users, bed frame dimensions, and as well as the type of bed frame. If you want a more discreet mattress, a thinner mattress might be more desirable than a thick mattress.
By Mattress Type
Mattress type refers to the material your mattress is made of. Here are some of the most common mattress types:
| Mattress Type | Best For | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| A memory foam mattress conforms to your body and provides pressure-point relief, weight distribution, and motion isolation. A common complaint with memory foam is its tendency to absorb heat, but many mattress brands, like those featured in this mattress guide, have developed technology to address this complaint. Additionally, bed-in-a-box style mattresses tend to be made of memory foam, which offer buyers a convenient way to shop for a mattress for the comfort of home.
| ||
 | Hybrid mattresses combine the comfort of memory foam with the support of springs. If you’re having trouble finding a mattress that works for you and your partner, this might be the perfect compromise. | ||
Recommended Mattress Brands
There are many quality mattress brands to choose from when you’re mattress shopping at local mattress stores. As one of the best mattress stores in Milwaukee, Colder’s stocks popular brands like Restonic and Sierra Sleep.
We’re also one of the top Restonic mattress retailers in Wisconsin, and we carry sister lines, including Scott Living, Scott Living Signature, and ComfortCare collections. Regardless of the mattress brand you select, we can offer a tailored mattress shopping experience to solves issues with your sleep.
Scott Living by Restonic Collection
Scott Living Mattress is a Restonic brand that offers a variety of mattress types, including hybrid, wrapped coil, and Euro top. Scott Living mattresses range in price from $1,000 to over $3,000.
Scott Living Signature by Restonic Collection
Scott Living Signature is a line of Restonic hybrid mattresses that ranges in price from over $1,500 to over $3,000. The collection offers luxury sleep quality with beautifully crafted bed models for fans of the hybrid mattress feel.
ComfortCare by Restonic Collection
From ComfortCare, you can find bed options at more affordable price. Depending on whether you select an innerspring, pocketed oil, or Euro top model, ComfortCare mattresses range in price from approximately $250 for a twin and just under $400 for a queen up to over $1,000 for a wrapped coil plush king mattress.
Sierra Sleep by Ashley
Sierra Sleep is one of Ashely Sleep’s mattress brands. Sierra Sleep aims to offer a quality and affordable mattress-in-a-box option. They offer mattresses, foundations, pillows, and bed frames. Their budget-friendly hybrid, innerspring, and memory foam mattresses range in price from under $300 to around $900.
If you’re looking to shop local for mattress Milwaukee supplier, you’ll need to compare not just the mattress brands that a store offers, but also the services of different mattress shops. At Colder’s, our mattress experts can offer plenty of tips and tricks for choosing the right mattress and promoting good sleep health.
Here are some of our other services:
- Colder's DoubleBack Program: For every $1 you spend on a mattress, you get $2 to spend on furniture! This can help you purchase a new bedroom set or furniture for another room in your home with a major discount.
- Mattress Sales: We regularly offer mattress sale campaigns, so continue to check back in to see what is on sale at the moment.
- Mattress Financing: A mattress is a big investment, and in-store financing can help you purchase the mattress of your dreams.
- Lifetime Delivery: Our Lifetime Delivery Program provides you with the opportunity to get furniture, appliance, and mattress delivery for life for one low price. You also gain access to curated benefits and exclusive offers.
Learn More: Shipping Deals Near Milwaukee: Colder’s Direct
Colder’s Reviews
Our reviews speak for themselves. See why when it comes to mattress stores Milwaukee shoppers count on, Colder’s consistently sits at the top of the list.
“…very knowledgeable with no pressure sales, able to buy exactly what we needed…These employees will make me want to return to buy more!!”
“My buying experience was very positive. The in store salesman was knowledgeable and did not pressure us during our discussion. We ordered online and that process was quick and easy.”
“My wife and I have always had a great experience at Colder's. We are repeat customers. Our most recent purchase was for a new mattress, box spring, and sofa…Setting up the delivery of the items was quick and easy! Would not hesitate to buy from them.”
4 Reasons We’re the Mattress Stores Milwaukee Chooses
There are several common sleep problems (tossing and turning, insomnia, sleep apnea, body pain, night sweats, and pressure points), but finding the right mattress can help improve your sleep health. Here are five mattress that show a glimpse of what to expect from Colder’s and why buyers choose us when it comes to mattress quality, price, and reliability.
Best Mattress for Sleepers with Joint Pain: Restonic Scott Living Ellis Hybrid Medium Plush Queen Mattress
This hybrid mattress is designed with several common sleep complaints in mind. Hot sleepers will love the triple cooling system with memory foam designed to absorb less heat. Meanwhile, MicroCoils provide a pressure-relieving surface for those with joint pain while the Q5 Twin Support system provides five targeted support zones to promote proper spinal alignment. Perfectly balanced with plush comfort at a medium level of support, this pick is a safe bet for all types of sleep positions.
Best Mattress for Budget-Minded Shoppers: Restonic Beltram Innerspring Firm Queen Mattress
This affordable innerspring mattress is designed to offer contouring support so that you wake up feeling rested and refreshed. Say goodbye to the aches and pains that come with a sagging mattress. This firm mattress is ideal for back and stomach sleepers and features exclusive Vert Coil technology for better support than traditional coil mattresses.
Best Mattress for Side Sleepers: Scott Living by Restonic Morgan Hybrid Plush Euro Top Queen Mattress in a Box
Shop This Scott Living Hybrid Mattress
This hybrid mattress combines cooling fabric technology, gel foam, super soft foam, AlumiLast memory foam, and MicroCoils encased in foam to provide unparalleled comfort and support. The result? A one-of-a-kind experience where hot sleeping and pressure points are virtually no more. This plush mattress feels like a cloud and is ideal for side sleepers, and best of all, it can be delivered right to your doorstep as a mattress-in-a-box option.
Best Mattress for Motion Isolation: Scott Living Ferndale Wrapped Coil Tight Top Plush King Mattress
Shop This Scott Living Pocket Coil Mattress
When you’re sharing a bed, you want a mattress designed to minimize motion disturbance. If your partner tends to toss and turn or if you want to shift positions without disturbing them, this wrapped coil mattress was designed with you in mind. Foam-encased coils give excellent edge-to-edge support, which extends the longevity of your mattress to prevent sagging. On top, gel-infused memory foam provides comfort and is designed to pull heat away from your body to maintain a cooler sleeping surface.
Prioritizing your sleep health and developing good sleep hygiene is beneficial for your overall health. That’s why choosing the right mattress is so important. At Colder’s, our experts can help you compare different mattress types and brands to find one that suits your needs. We’ll help you understand the options, assess your own sleeping habits, and guide you toward a mattress that targets your personal sleep complaints. From our customer service to DoubleBack savings, Colder’s is the best mattress store in Milwaukee.
Why Trust Colder’s?
Since 1942, we at Colder's pride ourselves on offering value, selection, and service. Serving Southeastern Wisconsin with four showrooms that stock quality name-brand furniture, appliances, and mattresses, Colder’s is sure to house exactly what you are looking for. And if you can't find it on our floors, chances are, we can order it for you. As a local, family-owned company, we are always doing our best to provide the highest value at the lowest cost to everyone who walks through our doors.
Colder’s is committed not only to continuously offering can’t-miss sales but also to working with each customer, making sure that you take advantage of every possible markdown — that’s our best price guarantee. Still need help? We offer zero percent appliance and furniture financing on your home needs!
Shop the Best Milwaukee Mattress Stores at Colder’s
Don’t put off happiness — and shop mattresses online for unbeatable prices at Colder’s. Our friendly experts are always happy to help you see how we’re one of the top-rated mattress stores Milwaukee homeowners can select, whether you call us at 414-476-1574 or use our online chat feature. Better yet, stop by one of our Colder’s locations in West Allis, Oak Creek, Delafield, and Grafton, Wisconsin to touch, see, feel, and experience home products that fulfill your dreams. Visit us today!
Learn More: Check Out Our Favorite Restonic Mattress Models [Brand Guide]