Colder's Best-Selling Mattresses & Shopping Tips

Huron Innerspring Euro Top Queen Mattress

Shop This Duet Sleep Mattress

You'll get a great night's sleep with the right combination of cushioning and support. This best innerspring mattress from Duet Sleep features a 650 LFK open coil system with foam encasement to deliver stability while reducing motion transfer. Multiple layers of SuperSoft Foam create a plush, pressure-relieving surface, while the TempBalance quilted layer helps regulate temperature for a more comfortable sleep environment. The reinforced edges expand the usable sleep area for consistent support across the entire mattress.

Scott Living™ Harbor 15" Hybrid Firm Tight Top Queen Mattress

Shop This Scott Living Firm Mattress

If you're looking for Colder’s mattresses with extra support and hybrid suspension, then you won't go wrong this model from the Harbor collection. This model features a triple cooling system, including AlumiLast Memory Foam and gel-infused quilting, to dissipate heat and maintain a refreshing sleep surface. Over 1,300 MicroCoils adapt instantly to movement, to give you responsive comfort, while the Q5 Twin Support system delivers targeted reinforcement for proper spinal alignment. A foam-encased edge expands the sleep surface and prevents sagging for lasting durability.

Scott Living™ Select Hybrid Plush Tight Top Queen Mattress

Shop This Scott Living Plush Mattress

Drifting into a deep sleep is effortless with a mattress designed for plush comfort and advanced cooling. A breathable cover with TempBalance Gel creates an instant cooling effect, while Gel Memory Foam relieves pressure and minimizes heat buildup. The Q5 Twin Support system delivers targeted reinforcement, for proper spinal alignment and extra support where it's needed most. VentiCool Fabric enhances airflow by 25% to maintain a refreshing sleep surface throughout the night.

Scott Living™ Anniversary 15" Hybrid Ultra Plush Euro Top Queen Mattress

Shop This Scott Living Hybrid Mattress

Luxury meets cloud-like softness in a mattress designed for those who crave ultra-plush comfort. A Euro top construction with multiple layers of Super Soft Foam provides deep, body-hugging relief, while a quilted gel foam layer adds a touch of cooling. Beneath the plush surface, 832 individually wrapped coils adapt to your movements, delivering targeted support and reducing motion transfer. A firmer perimeter edge enhances durability and extends the usable sleep surface.

Sierra Sleep® by Ashley® Millennium Hybrid Luxury Plush Tight Top Queen Mattress in a Box

Shop This Sierra Sleep Mattress

A plush, tight top with two layers of phase change material helps regulate temperature, while copper-infused memory foam dissipates heat and contours to the body. Sculpted comfort foam relieves pressure points, and a green tea-infused support foam base enhances freshness. Beneath the surface, a premium NanoCoil unit and individually wrapped coils provide targeted support and motion isolation, making this a great mattress for couples and a splurge for solo sleepers.

Sierra Sleep® by Ashley® Ultra Luxury Memory Foam Firm Tight Top Queen Mattress in a Box

Shop This Sierra Sleep Foam Mattress

If you’re in the market for a best selling foam mattress that doesn’t break the bank, this mattress under $1000 is a steal. Standing 14 inches tall, this design cradles the body while maintaining a sturdy, no-sink surface for proper spinal alignment. High-density memory foam adapts to movement that reduces pressure points and minimizes motion transfer for uninterrupted sleep. Its tight top construction provides a smooth, even feel which makes it ideal for those who prefer firmer support. Look out for a Colders mattress sale to bag this bed at an even greater price.

Shop Mattresses Like a Pro

Finding the perfect mattress starts with knowing what fits your sleep style, space, and budget. Whether you’re upgrading for comfort or need a better night’s sleep, narrowing down your options makes mattress shopping easier.

Determine Your Mattress Comfort

Mattress comfort levels vary, so choosing the right one depends on sleep position and personal preference. A plush mattress gives you a soft, cushioned feel, ideal for side sleepers who need pressure relief. These tend to be higher in price due to extra comfort layers.

On the other hand, a medium mattresses provide a balanced feel, so they’re great choices for couples or combination sleepers. They also supports various sleep positions and falls into a mid-range price point.

Those who prefer solid support should consider a firm mattress, which promotes proper spinal alignment and is best for back and stomach sleepers. You can shop for mattresses with a firm layer at Colder's in various sizes. 

Select the Right Mattress Size

Choosing the right mattress size ensures you have enough space to sleep comfortably. Explore Colder’s mattresses in all these different types and in various sizes with our in-house sleep center you can test the latest models in.

• A twin mattress is best for kids, dorm rooms, and compact spaces. For younger sleepers experience sprouting, opt for a twin XL mattress, which is about 5 inches longer.
• Full mattresses give you extra width so they're ideal for single adults or guest rooms.
• A queen mattress is the most popular size because it balances space and affordability for couples and individuals alike. At 80 inches long, they also provide the same amount of leg length as a king mattress.
• For maximum room, king/California king mattresses are perfect for those who share a bed or want extra sleeping space, though they come at a higher price.

To find the best size mattress Milwaukee has to offer, shop at Colder's whether you need a bed for your children or for you and your spouse, we have everything you need.

Select the Perfect Mattress Type

Material and construction impact the durability and feel of a mattress. Innerspring mattresses provide a traditional bounce with strong airflow, and they come at a budget-friendly price, but they’re not always so forgiving on side sleepers. On the other hand, wrapped coil mattresses reduce motion transfer, which makes them ideal for couples, and the independent motion is better at targeted support. Foam mattresses give you solid support and contouring, while memory foam enhances pressure relief with body-hugging comfort. A hybrid mattress blends coils and foam for the best of both worlds.

Explore Top Mattress Brands

Choosing the right mattress starts with finding a trusted brand. Each manufacturer gives you unique features, price points, and comfort options to fit different sleep needs.

• Restonic mattresses have been providing quality sleep solutions for over 80 years. Known for their award-winning designs, they focus on advanced support technologies like their patented Marvelous Middle, which enhances lumbar support. Restonic provides a range of models, from affordable to luxury which makes them a versatile choice.
• Scott Living Mattress is the exclusive line inspired by the Property Brothers that combines comfort and craftsmanship. These hybrid mattresses feature high-density foams and wrapped coils for targeted support, designed to provide long-lasting comfort with a touch of luxury.
• Sierra Sleep mattresses are part of the Ashley Furniture line and specializes in affordable mattress in a box options. These models give you memory foam, hybrid, and innerspring designs at budget-friendly prices, which makes them a convenient choice for online shoppers.
• Coaster mattresses are value-focused sleep solutions for budget shoppers. You get a mix of foam and innerspring options, and they provide budget-conscious buyers with reliable comfort and support.

Read the Fine Print| Mattress Warranties

A typical mattress warranty lasts 5 to 10 years and covers defects in materials or workmanship, such as sagging beyond a certain depth. However, a good mattress warranty should offer at least 10 years of coverage with clear terms on repairs or replacements.

For added protection, Colder's mattresses come with extended service plans upon request. Unlike standard warranties, these plans cover accidental damage and wear, to ensure long-term comfort.  This makes us one of the best mattress stores Milwaukee shoppers trust because you can benefit from Colder’s 5-year furniture service plan, which includes expert repairs and a replacement guarantee if issues persist.

Expert Tips: Finding the Best Mattress Deals

Wondering where to buy mattress models? Be sure to explore the Colder's mattress stores in Milwaukee with the best value offerings. Look for Clearance Mattresses or Colder’s Special Buys to score significant savings, or take advantage of mattress—especially those featuring the DoubleBack Mattress Program at Colder’s. With this program, you earn $2 in-store credit for every $1 spent on a Scott Living Mattress, which can be used on furniture! Plus, Colder’s lets you test mattresses on-site to find the perfect fit before committing. Visit in person for expert advice and great deals!

Set the Date to Shop for Your Next Mattress

Timing is everything when it comes to mattress shopping. Plan to visit Colder’s during popular sales events like Memorial Day, Labor Day, Black Friday, or New Year’s to get the best deals on Colder’s mattresses. These holidays feature significant discounts to help you save even more!

Shopping for mattresses at Colder’s vs big-box stores is a lot like sleep. Once you skimp on quality, you end up paying for what you get—so choose the best for your sleep help by shopping for best-selling mattresses from our selection! With top brands and all the styles for every sleeper, tailored sleep starts by choosing a winning mattress model from our selection!

Why Trust Colder’s?

Since 1942, we at Colder's pride ourselves on offering value, selection, and service. Serving Southeastern Wisconsin with four showrooms that stock quality name-brand furniture, appliances, and mattresses, Colder’s is sure to house exactly what you are looking for. And if you can't find it on our floors, chances are, we can order it for you. As a local, family-owned company, we are always doing our best to provide the highest value at the lowest cost to everyone who walks through our doors.

Colder’s is committed not only to continuously offering can’t-miss sales but also to working with each customer, making sure that you take advantage of every possible markdown — that’s our best price guarantee. Still need help? We offer zero percent appliance and furniture financing for your home needs!

Shop Mattresses at Colder’s

Don’t put off happiness — and shop mattresses online for unbeatable prices at Colder’s. Our friendly experts are always happy to help you see why Colders mattresses is the best selection around, whether you call us at 414-476-1574 or use our online chat feature. Better yet, stop by one of our Colder’s locations in West Allis, Oak Creek, Delafield, and Grafton, Wisconsin to touch, see, feel, and experience home products that fulfill your dreams. Visit us today!

Learn More: When is the Best Time to Buy a Mattress?

• Subscribe to Our Email List
• Shop Furniture Deals
• Shop Appliance Deals
• Shop Mattress Deals
• Learn About Our Services
• Learn About Financing Option